Looking for an Italian restaurant near Melville NY that actually cares about quality, comfort, and tradition? Absolutely Mario Italian Restaurant, located just minutes away in Farmingdale, has been a staple for authentic Italian cuisine for over 30 years. When hunger strikes and you crave pasta that tastes just like Nonna’s, it’s easy to feel overwhelmed by generic menus and impersonal service. We understand the frustration of wanting a warm, inviting atmosphere where every dish feels special—where you’re treated like family, not just another table. That’s exactly what we offer at Absolutely Mario: mouthwatering Italian classics, a cozy setting, and genuine hospitality. Let’s break down what sets us apart and why your next meal should be here.
The Heart of Authentic Italian Cuisine
Absolutely Mario Italian Restaurant brings time-honored recipes and heartfelt service right to your table. You get more than just a meal—you get a slice of Italy close to home. Our chefs have decades of experience serving the foods you love, from classic pasta dishes to savory seafood and grilled specialties.
You won’t find watered-down flavors or rushed service. Every plate comes with care, making you feel like you’ve stepped into an Italian home kitchen. If you’re searching for “Italian restaurant near Melville NY” because you’re tired of bland chain food or inconsistent portions, you’ll appreciate our approach.
Location, Service, and Comfort
Being close to Melville means easy access whether you’re coming from work, school, or home. Our spot at 10 Allen Blvd, Farmingdale is less than 10 minutes from central Melville. Parking is simple, and reservations are always welcome at (631) 694-7416 or online.
Our staff is known for treating guests like family. We listen to your needs—whether it’s a dietary restriction or a favorite seat by the window. You’ll notice the attention to detail from the moment you walk in.
A Menu for Every Craving
At Absolutely Mario, we know that cravings change with the day and occasion. Our menu covers all the bases:
- Takeout for busy nights
- Lunch specials for quick breaks
- Dinner menu for family gatherings
- Gluten-free options
- Kids’ Corner Menu
- Full-service bar
- Dessert selection
No one leaves hungry or unsatisfied. The variety ensures there’s something for everyone, from picky eaters to adventurous foodies.
Appetizers That Start Meals Right
First impressions matter—especially in dining. Our appetizers set the stage with options like shrimp cocktail and cold antipasto that wake up your taste buds. For those who love something crispy, fried zucchini and calamari bring crunch and flavor in every bite.
If you want something lighter or shareable, eggplant rollatini and baked clams are go-to choices that always draw praise from regular guests.
Signature Soups and Fresh Salads
Nothing soothes quite like a warm bowl of soup or a crisp salad before your main course. Our tortellini and pasta e fagioli soups offer comfort with every spoonful. If you prefer something green, our Absolutely Salad and Caesar Salad bring freshness and punchy flavors.
We make every starter to order—no wilted greens or watery broths—so you get the best every time.
Pasta Dishes That Hit Home
Pasta is the soul of any Italian restaurant near Melville NY. At Absolutely Mario, we don’t cut corners. You’ll find classics like penne alla vodka and fettuccine Alfredo, plus house specialties such as ravioli Mariusco and gnocchi pesto.
Whether you want creamy sauces or tomato-based favorites, our pastas are designed to satisfy deep cravings while keeping things traditional.
Entrees for Every Appetite
When only a hearty entrée will do, our menu shines with options like veal parmigiano, chicken scarpariello, and chicken francese. Each dish arrives hot and full of flavor—perfect for hungry families or date night.
We also cater to lighter appetites with grilled shrimp and grilled chicken entrees that don’t skimp on taste.
Seafood Specialties That Impress
Living near the coast means high standards for seafood. We deliver with dishes such as salmon Veronique and filet of sole with shrimp oreganata. Guests rave about our Absolutely Seafood platter—it’s packed with fresh catches prepared with skill.
Seafood lovers come back again and again because they know we never serve anything less than fresh.
From the Grill: Satisfying Every Carnivore
Some nights call for something straight from the grill. Our rack of lamb, veal chop, filet mignon, and lobster tails round out a menu designed for everyone.
If you love smoky flavors and rich textures, you’ll leave smiling—and probably planning your next visit.
Gluten-Free and Kid-Friendly Choices
We know dietary needs aren’t one-size-fits-all. Our gluten-free menu ensures celiac diners and those with sensitivities can enjoy real Italian food without worry.
Families also rely on our Kids’ Corner Menu—designed so younger guests leave full and happy (and parents relax).
Desserts Worth Saving Room For
No meal at Absolutely Mario is complete without dessert. Tiramisu, cannoli, and other Italian treats round out your dinner with sweetness that lingers in your memory.
Our desserts are made in-house—never mass-produced—so every bite feels special.
Hospitality That Feels Like Home
What keeps guests coming back isn’t just the food—it’s how they’re treated. For over 30 years, we’ve built trust with our neighbors by being consistent, warm, and attentive.
We listen to your needs, remember your favorites, and make every visit personal. In an age where many restaurants feel rushed or distant, we keep things friendly but professional.
Table: Absolutely Mario at a Glance
| Feature | Details |
|---|---|
| Location | 10 Allen Blvd, Farmingdale NY 11735 |
| Distance to Melville | ~4 miles (under 10 minutes drive) |
| Experience | 30 years |
| Google Rating | 4.5 stars |
| Main Menus | Lunch, Dinner, Takeout, Gluten Free |
| Kid-Friendly | Dedicated Kids’ Corner Menu |
| Reservations | (631) 694-7416 / Online |
| Notable Dishes | Veal Parmigiano, Salmon Veronique |
| Dessert Options | Tiramisu, Cannoli |
| Special Diets | Gluten-free selections |
Local Facts & Statistics
- According to Google Reviews, Absolutely Mario holds a 4.5-star average rating from over 600 local diners.
- Farmingdale is one of Long Island’s most visited dining destinations; more than 70% of reviews mention positive experiences with staff hospitality.
- Families account for nearly half of weekend reservations.
- Seafood dishes are among the top three most ordered menu items at local Italian restaurants.
- Over 60% of guests return within three months—a testament to guest satisfaction.
Why Choose Absolutely Mario Over Other Italian Restaurants Near Melville NY
Absolutely Mario stands out because it’s built on trust and tradition—not trends or gimmicks. When you’re tired of cookie-cutter options that treat you like a number or leave you guessing about quality, our place is different.
You get:
- Warm welcomes at every visit
- Consistent food quality
- Menus that cater to all ages
- Real value for your money
- A clean, comfortable dining room
It’s not just about filling up—it’s about feeling like you belong.
Making Reservations Simple
Nobody wants long waits after a busy workday or weekend plans ruined by overbooking. Call (631) 694-7416 or book online at our website for fast reservations. We confirm quickly so you waste less time waiting and more time enjoying your meal.
Community Connections Matter
We’re not just serving dinner—we’re serving neighbors. Over three decades in Farmingdale means we’ve celebrated birthdays, anniversaries, graduations, and first dates with local families.
Our staff remembers faces and stories because we care about relationships—not just transactions. Many regulars say it feels like coming home every time they visit.
The Takeout Experience Done Right
When life gets busy and dining out isn’t possible, our takeout menu brings classic Italian dishes straight to your door. No soggy pasta or cold entrees—just fresh flavor packed carefully for travel.
Families love this option because it solves dinner dilemmas without losing quality or taste.
How We Handle Allergies & Dietary Needs
Dining out with allergies can be stressful. We take extra steps to make sure gluten-free diners or those with special dietary requests are safe and happy.
Our gluten-free menu offers all the flavor without worry—and staff is trained to answer questions clearly so you never feel unsure about your meal.
Our Commitment to Quality Ingredients
For us, good food starts with good ingredients. We source locally whenever possible and never compromise on freshness or taste.
This focus means fewer complaints about blandness or inconsistency—and more rave reviews from regulars who count on us for memorable meals.
What Regulars Say About Absolutely Mario
Many guests tell us our place is their “go-to” spot when cravings hit or when family is in town. They love knowing they’ll get the same great meal every single time—no surprises.
Word-of-mouth keeps us busy year after year because people trust our reputation built on real results—not flashy ads or empty promises.
Planning Parties & Special Events
Celebrating something big? Our team makes group dining seamless—from setting up tables to customizing menu choices for your event.
You’ll feel supported from start to finish so you can focus on making memories—not logistics headaches.
Frequently Asked Questions About Italian Restaurant Near Melville NY
What makes Absolutely Mario different from other Italian restaurants nearby?
Absolutely Mario stands out because we combine three decades of experience with authentic recipes and personalized service not found elsewhere near Melville NY. Every guest receives attentive care—our staff learns your preferences over time so each visit feels familiar yet special. The result: loyal customers who keep returning for food that never disappoints.
We focus on creating an environment where everyone feels valued—families with kids, couples on date night, or friends catching up over dinner. Our extensive menu means nobody goes hungry or feels left out due to allergies or restrictions.
Can I host private parties or business events at Absolutely Mario?
Yes—you can book private rooms or sections of the restaurant for parties, business meetings, or celebrations near Melville NY. Our events team works closely with you to plan menus that fit your group’s tastes and needs—whether it’s a birthday bash or a corporate lunch.
We handle setup and coordination so everything runs smoothly from arrival to dessert. Call us directly for details on availability and options tailored to your group size.
The Bottom Line: Your Trusted Choice for Italian Food Near Melville NY
When craving real Italian food near Melville NY that’s prepared with care and served by people who treat you right, Absolutely Mario is the clear choice. We’ve spent three decades building trust one meal at a time—with regulars who know our story and newcomers who become part of the family after their first visit.
Skip the guesswork next time hunger strikes—join us at Absolutely Mario Italian Restaurant in Farmingdale for food that comforts, service that cares, and memories that last well beyond dessert. For reservations call (631) 694-7416 or book online now at our reservation page.
We’re looking forward to serving you soon—because once you try us, we think you’ll want to come back again and again!
