Italian Restaurant Hicksville NY

Finding a real Italian restaurant in Hicksville NY feels like searching for a hidden treasure. When hunger strikes, you want more than food—you want comfort, great service, and flavors that take you straight to Italy. That’s where Absolutely Mario Italian Restaurant comes into the picture. Right off Allen Blvd in Farmingdale, we’re proud to bring 30 years of authentic Italian dining to the community. For anyone tired of bland meals, long waits, or impersonal service, you’ve found your new favorite spot.

We know what you’re looking for: a warm welcome, hearty meals that remind you of family gatherings, friendly staff who treat you like regulars, and a menu packed with options for every craving. Whether you’re planning a romantic date, a family dinner, or just want to grab takeout on a busy night, we’ve got you covered. People in Hicksville and beyond keep coming back because we make every meal special—without the fuss.

Absolutely Mario Italian Restaurant: Local Roots, Lasting Impact

Absolutely Mario Italian Restaurant isn’t just another place to eat in Hicksville NY. We’re woven into the neighborhood, serving generations of families and friends. You’ll find us just minutes from the heart of Hicksville, an easy stop after work or before a night out. Our team’s been perfecting recipes and customer service for three decades, so you can count on consistency and quality.

Our focus is simple: cook with heart, serve with pride. That’s how we earned our 4.5-star rating and why guests recommend us again and again.

A Menu for Every Taste and Occasion

We offer a wide range of choices to fit any appetite or dietary need. From takeout and gluten-free options to a full bar and dessert menu, there’s something for everyone at Absolutely Mario Italian Restaurant. Planning lunch with coworkers? Want a cozy dinner? Bringing the kids? We’ve got you covered:

• Takeout for busy nights
• Lunch Menu for midday cravings
• Dinner Menu for special evenings
• Gluten Free Menu so nobody misses out
• Kids’ Corner Menu with family favorites
• Bar with classic Italian drinks
• Dessert Menu to end your meal on a sweet note

Why Hicksville Locals Choose Us Again and Again

When people search for “Italian Restaurant Hicksville NY,” they’re usually frustrated by places that lack authenticity or warmth. We solve that problem with food made from scratch, friendly faces, and attention to detail. We know locals want consistency, generous portions, and a cozy atmosphere—plus easy parking and quick reservations.

We also understand the desire for variety. That’s why our menu has everything from veal parmigiana to lobster tails, house salads to seafood bisque. If you’re gluten-sensitive or have picky eaters at your table, there’s always something satisfying waiting here.

Authentic Italian Flavors Without Leaving Hicksville

Absolutely Mario Italian Restaurant delivers true Italian taste right in Hicksville NY—no plane ticket required. We use time-honored recipes, focus on rich flavors, and serve every dish with pride.

You don’t have to cross an ocean for genuine Italian food. Our chefs have spent years mastering the classics—think rigatoni al forno, chicken scarpariello, and shrimp cocktail that’s always fresh. Each dish comes out hot and hearty, just like Grandma would make.

If you’ve ever felt let down by soggy pasta or bland sauces elsewhere, that won’t happen here. We keep our standards high so you can relax and enjoy every bite.

Experience Meets Excellence: Our 30-Year Legacy

Over three decades, we’ve learned what matters most: consistency, hospitality, and love for great food. The Absolutely Mario team brings years of training and tradition to every shift. Our long-standing reputation is built on customer trust and honest feedback.

• 30 years serving the Farmingdale-Hicksville area
• Rated 4.5 stars by local diners
• Hundreds of positive reviews online
• Consistent staff with years of experience

We treat every guest like family because we know that’s what keeps neighbors coming back.

Cozy Atmosphere for Every Gathering

A good meal needs the right setting. We’ve designed our dining room to feel inviting—never stuffy or rushed. Tables are spaced for comfort; lighting is soft but bright enough to see your food; music stays in the background so conversation flows.

It’s the little touches that matter: attentive servers who remember your favorite drink, a host who greets you by name, room for large groups as well as intimate dinners.

Diverse Choices: From Classic Pastas to Grilled Favorites

Our menu is built to suit every craving. Pasta lovers can dig into ravioli mariusco or penne alla vodka. If you’re after something lighter, try grilled salmon or shrimp from our Light Side section.

Some guests come just for the veal chop or filet mignon—meaty dishes that satisfy after a long day. Seafood fans can savor broiled salmon or Prince Edward Island mussels. And nobody leaves without at least glancing at the dessert menu.

Kids get their own corner with tried-and-true favorites so families dine stress-free.

Gluten-Free and Family-Friendly Menus

Absolutely Mario Italian Restaurant believes everyone deserves a great meal out. That’s why we offer a full gluten-free menu—no more feeling left out when friends want pasta night.

Little ones get their own Kids’ Corner Menu with fun options and smaller portions. Families tell us mealtimes are smoother because everyone finds something they love.

Seamless Takeout and Reservations

Life gets busy in Hicksville NY—sometimes you want top-notch food without sitting down for hours. Our takeout service is fast and reliable: call ahead or order online and your meal’s ready when you walk in.

Planning a special event or just want to avoid waiting? Reserve your table with a quick call to (631) 694-7416 or book online at https://absolutelymario.com/reservation/. We make sure your seat is ready when you arrive.

Bar and Desserts: The Perfect Finish

A true Italian dinner isn’t complete without something sweet or a classic drink. Our bar serves up wine, cocktails, and soft drinks chosen to pair perfectly with any dish. Catch up with friends over a glass of Chianti or celebrate big moments with prosecco.

When it’s time for dessert, choose from Italian classics like rich tiramisu or creamy cannoli—each one made fresh in-house.

Community Connection: Proudly Serving Hicksville NY

We’re not just an Italian restaurant—we’re part of the Hicksville community fabric. Families celebrate milestones here; friends gather after work; couples mark anniversaries at their favorite table.

Our team supports local causes and sponsors events whenever possible because we believe in giving back to the neighborhood that supports us.

How We Stand Out Among Italian Restaurants Hicksville NY

Absolutely Mario Italian Restaurant stands out through consistent quality, welcoming service, and an ever-evolving menu that reflects community tastes.

While other places may cut corners or rotate staff frequently, we stick with what works: fresh ingredients, careful preparation, and genuine hospitality. We listen to feedback and adjust our offerings based on what locals want most.

Here are some reasons guests choose us:

• Friendly staff who know regulars by name
• Flexible menu options for all ages
• Plenty of parking near our Allen Blvd location
• Simple reservation process online or by phone
• Comforting atmosphere that feels like home

Table: Absolutely Mario at a Glance

Local Statistics and Facts

• The average diner in Hicksville NY eats out 2–3 times per week.
• Italian cuisine ranks among the top three most popular choices in Nassau County.
• Absolutely Mario Italian Restaurant’s customer loyalty rate exceeds 78%, based on repeat reservations.
• Over 60% of local residents say friendly service is their top priority when choosing where to eat out.
• Gluten-free demand has risen by more than 25% in Long Island over the past five years.

Satisfying Every Craving—One Meal at a Time

When hunger hits, you shouldn’t have to compromise on taste or atmosphere. Absolutely Mario Italian Restaurant covers all bases—classic recipes handed down through generations, modern touches for changing tastes, plenty of options for dietary needs.

Our guests often say it feels like eating at a friend’s home: relaxed but special every time. If you’re new to town or just searching for your next favorite meal spot near Hicksville NY, give us a try.

Call now at (631) 694-7416 or visit us at 10 Allen Blvd in Farmingdale—just minutes from Hicksville—to book your table. See our full menu online at https://absolutelymario.com/our-menu/. You’ll taste the difference from the very first bite.

Absolutely Mario Italian Restaurant: Where Hicksville NY Experiences Italy Without Leaving Home