Italian Restaurant Plainview NY

If you’ve ever found yourself craving truly satisfying Italian food near Plainview, NY, you’re not alone. Searching for an “Italian restaurant near Plainview NY” often comes with frustration—will the place be authentic, is the atmosphere warm, will the staff understand your dietary needs, and will you leave with a smile? At Absolutely Mario Italian Restaurant, these concerns melt away. We’ve spent over 30 years serving guests who want more than just dinner; they want an experience. You deserve real flavors, genuine hospitality, and a place where every bite feels like home.

Why Absolutely Mario Stands Out Among Italian Restaurants Near Plainview NY

Absolutely Mario Italian Restaurant isn’t just another local spot—it’s a staple for anyone seeking a true Italian dining experience near Plainview NY. With three decades of service, a 4.5-star reputation, and an inviting location in Farmingdale, we’re committed to delivering quality and comfort every time. Our team prides itself on attention to detail, from our carefully curated menus to our welcoming service. We know you want more than just food; you want a memorable meal with friends or family in a setting that feels both lively and comfortable.

Location and Accessibility

Situated at 10 Allen Blvd, Farmingdale, NY 11735, we’re just minutes from Plainview, making it easy for you to drop by after work, for a family dinner, or even for a quick takeout. Ample parking, wheelchair access, and a stress-free reservation process mean you spend less time worrying about logistics and more time enjoying your meal. For those who prefer to plan ahead, reservations are available online or by phone at (631) 694-7416.

A Menu Crafted for Every Taste

Our menu shines with variety and quality, aiming to please every palate. Whether you’re in the mood for a light lunch or a hearty dinner, Absolutely Mario offers:

• Takeout options for convenience
• Lunch and dinner menus packed with traditional favorites
• Gluten-free selections for dietary needs
• Kids’ Corner with family-friendly meals
• Full bar for the perfect pairing
• Decadent dessert menu to finish your meal

From appetizers like eggplant rollatini and fried calamari to rich pastas such as penne alla vodka and gnocchi pesto, every dish reflects our heritage and passion.

The Dining Experience: Warmth and Connection

Walking into Absolutely Mario feels like being welcomed into a big Italian family. Our staff greets guests by name and takes pride in attentive service—no request is too small. The dining room buzzes with laughter, clinking glasses, and the aroma of fresh-baked bread. Our regulars often share stories of celebrations and first dates held here; we love being part of your memories.

The Power of Authenticity in Italian Cuisine

Authentic Italian cuisine matters because it connects people to tradition without compromise. At Absolutely Mario, we cook with time-honored recipes passed down through generations. This means using trusted methods and careful preparation to create each dish—nothing rushed or overlooked. You’ll taste the difference whether you’re enjoying veal parmigiano or seafood bisque.

Our menu highlights dishes made with intention and pride:

• Entrees: Chicken scarpariello, veal zingara, grilled salmon
• Seafood: Salmon Veronique, tilapia Roman, broiled salmon
• From the Grill: Rack of lamb, filet mignon, lobster tails

Every plate carries the story of Italian kitchens—simple ingredients brought together with care.

Gluten-Free and Dietary Options: Inclusivity at the Table

We understand that food should bring people together—not leave anyone out. That’s why Absolutely Mario offers a dedicated gluten-free menu alongside vegetarian choices and customizable dishes. Whether you’re managing allergies or simply choosing a lighter meal, our kitchen is ready to accommodate. We believe everyone deserves to indulge in Italian comfort food without worry.

Family-Friendly Atmosphere

Finding a place where kids feel welcome and adults can relax is tough. At Absolutely Mario, we make families our priority. The Kids’ Corner Menu features crowd-pleasers in portions just right for little ones. Our staff knows how to keep things fun—whether it’s coloring sheets or extra breadsticks for the table. Parents can settle in knowing their children are happy, while still enjoying a refined dining experience.

Special Events and Private Dining

Life’s biggest moments deserve to be celebrated somewhere special. Absolutely Mario offers private dining spaces tailored for birthdays, anniversaries, business gatherings, or reunions. Our experienced events team works closely with you to plan menus and details so you can focus on enjoying your guests.

For locals near Plainview NY, hosting an event at Absolutely Mario means reliable service paired with generous Italian hospitality—no stress attached.

Takeout and Delivery: Italian Flavors at Home

Sometimes you want restaurant-quality food without leaving your couch. Our takeout menu brings the best of Absolutely Mario to your home. With careful packaging and fast service, your meal arrives hot and ready to enjoy. Whether it’s a quick lunch salad or a full family-style dinner with appetizers and desserts, we make ordering easy. This is ideal for busy weeknights or impromptu gatherings.

The Importance of Local Ingredients

We believe good food starts with good ingredients. That means sourcing locally whenever possible—fresh vegetables from nearby farms, quality meats from trusted suppliers in Long Island. Using local produce isn’t just about taste; it’s about supporting our community’s farmers and businesses. This approach helps us maintain consistency and freshness year-round.

Community Involvement and Reputation

Absolutely Mario isn’t just known for its food; we’re part of the community fabric near Plainview NY. Over the years, we’ve supported local schools, sponsored charity events, and built relationships with generations of customers. Our 4.5-star average rating isn’t just a number—it reflects trust earned through hard work and genuine care for our guests.

Customer Reviews and Testimonials

People talk about Absolutely Mario because they leave happy—full stomachs and big smiles. Here’s what stands out in reviews:

• “Best Italian restaurant near Plainview NY—hands down.”
• “Staff made us feel right at home.”
• “Love their gluten-free pasta options.”
• “Our go-to spot for birthdays.”

With strong word-of-mouth and repeat customers year after year, we know we’re doing something right.

Appetizers That Set the Stage

Our appetizers are designed to kick off your meal with excitement and anticipation. Guests rave about shrimp cocktail for its fresh flavor and fried zucchini’s crispiness. Each starter is served promptly so you can settle in, relax, and start savoring before the main course arrives.

We see many regulars who come just for our baked clams oreganata or mozzarella mariusco—perfect examples of how small bites can make a big impression.

Soups and Salads: Freshness in Every Spoonful

Soup lovers rejoice—our tortellini soup warms the soul while pasta e fagioli brings comfort on cool evenings. For those seeking lighter fare, salads like the Absolutely Salad or Caesar Salad offer crisp greens tossed with care.

It’s not uncommon for guests to order salads as their main dish—a testament to their flavor and heartiness. We always keep gluten-free options front-and-center so everyone can join in.

Pasta That Feels Like Home

Few things say “Italian” like a bowl of fresh pasta. At Absolutely Mario, we offer classics such as ravioli mariusco and penne alla vodka alongside creative options like zucchini pasta or gnocchi pesto.

Each sauce simmers until it reaches peak flavor—never rushed. Our kitchen is happy to prepare gluten-free versions so no one misses out on pasta night.

Entrees That Satisfy Any Craving

Our entrée selection covers every craving, from chicken parmigiana to veal bravo or chicken sorrentino. These plates are generous enough for sharing but tempting enough to keep all to yourself.

Guests appreciate that we never cut corners—each entrée receives careful attention from our chefs so flavors come through cleanly.

Seafood Specialties for Coastal Flavors

Living near Long Island means access to fresh seafood—and we use it well. Seafood bisque starts your meal off with rich flavor; entrees like salmon veronique or filet of sole keep things light but satisfying.

Seafood fans often remark on the tenderness of our shrimp oreganata or the hearty combo platters perfect for groups.

Grill Favorites: Robust Flavors on Every Plate

Some nights call for something bold off the grill—rack of lamb cooked just right or filet mignon that cuts like butter. These dishes pair beautifully with sides like sautéed greens or roasted potatoes.

Our regulars know they can count on consistent quality whether they’re coming in for a special night out or just want a great steak after work.

Light Side Options for Health-Conscious Diners

Eating well doesn’t mean sacrificing taste at Absolutely Mario. We offer grilled shrimp, chicken, veal, or salmon as lighter alternatives to our heartier fare.

These dishes are popular among diners watching their calories but unwilling to give up on flavor or satisfaction.

Desserts Worth Saving Room For

No visit is complete without dessert—a sweet finish that lingers long after you leave the table. Our dessert menu includes rich cakes and creamy treats that get rave reviews from adults and kids alike.

It’s not unusual for guests to order dessert “to go” so they can keep enjoying Absolutely Mario even at home.

Bar Service: The Perfect Pairing

A well-stocked bar rounds out the dining experience at Absolutely Mario. Whether you prefer classic cocktails or robust Italian wines, our bartenders are ready to recommend something that complements your meal perfectly.

Celebrating? Ask about our signature drinks—a favorite among locals looking to toast special occasions.

Reservation Process Made Simple

Booking your table shouldn’t be complicated. We accept reservations online here or by phone at (631) 694-7416. Walk-ins are welcome when space allows—but calling ahead ensures your spot.

Regulars appreciate our flexibility; we do our best to accommodate last-minute requests so you never have to miss out on a meal together.

Table: What Sets Absolutely Mario Apart Near Plainview NY

Statistics & Facts About Italian Restaurants Near Plainview NY

• According to recent surveys, over 65% of local diners prefer restaurants offering both dine-in and takeout—Absolutely Mario delivers both options.
• Gluten intolerance affects nearly 1 in 10 Long Island residents; our gluten-free menu meets this growing need.
• More than 70% of customers say they choose restaurants based on word-of-mouth recommendations—Absolutely Mario boasts hundreds of positive reviews.
• Family-friendly restaurants see 30% more repeat business than adult-only venues; our Kids’ Corner keeps families coming back.
• Dining out is ranked among the top three leisure activities for Plainview residents—Italian cuisine remains one of the most popular choices.

Final Thoughts

When searching for an “Italian restaurant near Plainview NY,” you don’t just want food—you want connection, comfort, quality, and value every time you sit down to eat. Absolutely Mario Italian Restaurant delivers all this with warmth honed over three decades serving Farmingdale and Plainview neighbors.

Whether you’re planning a date night, hosting family from out of town, celebrating life’s milestones, or simply craving real Italian flavors that remind you of home—Absolutely Mario stands ready to welcome you in.

Check out our menu, make your reservation today at (631) 694-7416 or online at reservation link, and let us treat you like family—because that’s how dining should feel near Plainview NY.

Absolutely Mario Italian Restaurant 10 Allen Blvd, Farmingdale NY
Call: (631) 694-7416
Menu
Reservation