Looking for the best Italian restaurant in Farmingdale NY? We get it—choosing where to dine out isn’t just about food. It’s about memories, comfort, and that sense of home away from home. You want authentic Italian food, generous portions, and a cozy atmosphere. But what if the pasta is bland, the service unfriendly, or the wait too long? At Absolutely Mario Italian Restaurant, we understand those frustrations. That’s why we promise not just a meal, but a warm welcome and a true taste of Italy right here in Farmingdale. With over 30 years of experience, a loyal local following, and a 4.5-star rating, we’ve made sure every guest walks out smiling and satisfied.
A Legacy of Authentic Italian Food
Absolutely Mario Italian Restaurant has become a staple for Italian cuisine in Farmingdale NY over the last three decades. The focus is on authenticity, quality, and hospitality. Locals know us for our outstanding pasta dishes, savory seafood, and classic entrees that keep families coming back. Our menu reflects the rich traditions of Italian cooking—honest, hearty meals served with pride.
Warm and Inviting Atmosphere
Step through our doors and you’ll notice more than just the aroma of simmering sauces. The setting is cozy and beautifully decorated, perfect for family gatherings, romantic dinners, or celebrating milestones. We believe dining should be comfortable—like visiting an old friend’s home. Our friendly staff greets you by name and makes sure you’re well taken care of from start to finish.
Extensive Menu for Every Taste
Cravings don’t come in one size. That’s why Absolutely Mario offers an extensive menu:
- Takeout for busy nights
- Lunch and dinner options
- Gluten-free menu
- Kids’ Corner for younger guests
- Well-stocked bar
- Decadent dessert selections
With choices ranging from classic veal parmigiano to fresh grilled shrimp and hearty pasta favorites, every appetite is covered.
Appetizers That Set the Tone
Start your meal with house favorites like shrimp cocktail, fried calamari, or mozzarella mariusco. Each appetizer promises to tease your palate without overshadowing the main event. The cold antipasto and baked clams oreganata are also local favorites, loved for their fresh flavors and satisfying portions.
These appetizers are more than just starters—they’re the first impression of what’s to come. They set the tone for a memorable meal.
Classic Italian Soups
Soup lovers will appreciate traditional options like tortellini soup, pasta e fagioli, and seafood bisque. Our soups are crafted with care, simmered to perfection, and always served piping hot.
They’re the kind of soups that warm you up on a chilly Long Island evening—a comforting reminder of hearty Italian kitchens.
Crisp Salads for Freshness
Salads like the Absolutely Salad and Caesar Salad offer a refreshing contrast to rich entrees. We use crisp greens, quality dressings, and fresh toppings that complement every main course.
For those seeking lighter fare or a healthy start to their meal, our warm spinach salad and house mixed salad hit the spot.
Pasta Dishes That Stand Out
Pasta is the heart of Italian cuisine—and ours doesn’t disappoint. Try ravioli mariusco stuffed with flavor or penne alla vodka for a creamy classic. Our fettuccine alfredo is rich without being heavy, while farfalle primavera bursts with seasonal vegetables.
We also offer gluten-free options so everyone can enjoy their favorite dishes worry-free.
Entrees for Every Preference
Our entrees showcase Italian comfort food at its best—think chicken scarpariello, veal parmigiano, and chicken francese. These dishes are prepared with tradition in mind and plated to please both eyes and palate.
For those seeking lighter options, grilled salmon or chicken are available—each dish crafted with the same attention to detail as our heartier classics.
Seafood Specialties
Seafood lovers find plenty to cheer about with our salmon veronique, filet of sole and shrimp oreganata, or the signature Absolutely Seafood platter. These dishes offer fresh flavors straight from the coast of Italy to your table in Farmingdale.
The broiled salmon is a crowd-pleaser—tender and perfectly seasoned every time.
From the Grill: Satisfying Every Craving
If you’re in the mood for something from the grill, try our rack of lamb or filet mignon. These dishes are cooked just right and served with sides that bring out their best. The lobster tails are another standout for those craving something special.
We believe grilling brings out authentic flavors—and our guests agree.
Lighter Choices with Big Flavor
For those watching their portions but not willing to sacrifice taste, our Light Side menu offers grilled shrimp, chicken, veal, or salmon. These options are nourishing without feeling less indulgent—a perfect lunch or dinner choice when you want something satisfying but not too heavy.
Our guests love these dishes for their simplicity and bold flavors.
Kid-Friendly Dining
Families know how stressful dining out can be if kids aren’t happy. That’s why our Kids’ Corner menu is filled with familiar favorites that keep little ones satisfied. We serve kid-sized portions of pasta and other comfort foods so parents can relax and enjoy their own meal.
Dining out should be easy for everyone—and we make sure it is.
Sweet Endings: Dessert Menu Highlights
No meal is complete without dessert. Indulge in classic Italian treats from our dessert menu after your meal—each sweet bite a nod to traditional family recipes.
Whether you’re celebrating or just treating yourself, these desserts leave a lasting impression.
Bar and Beverages
Pair your meal with a drink from our well-stocked bar. From wine to spirits and non-alcoholic options, there’s something for everyone.
Raise a glass to good times and great company.
Why Absolutely Mario Is the Best Italian Restaurant in Farmingdale NY
Absolutely Mario stands out because we put people first—both in the kitchen and at your table. Our focus on high-quality food at reasonable prices means you never have to compromise between taste and value. Portions are generous; you’ll never leave hungry.
Our staff take pride in knowing regulars by name and making newcomers feel welcome from their first visit. With over 30 years serving Farmingdale NY, we’ve earned our reputation through consistency and attention to detail.
Pain Points Solved at Absolutely Mario
Dining out should be relaxing—not stressful or disappointing. Here’s how we solve common pain points:
- Tired of bland pasta? Our recipes burst with flavor.
- Frustrated by small portions? We serve hearty plates.
- Worried about dietary needs? Check out our gluten-free menu.
- Sick of noisy restaurants? Our cozy atmosphere keeps things comfortable.
- Want friendly staff? Our team treats everyone like family.
- Need fast takeout? We make it easy.
- Dining with kids? Our kids’ menu takes care of picky eaters.
- Craving authentic Italian? You’ll taste tradition in every bite.
Desires Fulfilled at Absolutely Mario
We know what makes dining out special:
- You want memorable meals with friends or family.
- You crave authentic Italian food made with care.
- You look for cozy restaurants with great atmosphere.
- You need generous portions at fair prices.
- You appreciate attentive service from staff who care.
- You love having gluten-free options.
- You want a place that feels like home.
Absolutely Mario delivers on all these desires—night after night.
Local Flavor: Serving Farmingdale NY With Pride
Being part of Farmingdale means more than just serving food—it’s about community. We support local events, sponsor neighborhood causes, and welcome locals as friends. Our restaurant has seen generations celebrate milestones within its walls—from first dates to anniversaries to birthdays.
We’re proud to represent Farmingdale’s spirit of hospitality and warmth.
Dining Experience: What Guests Say
Our 4.5-star rating speaks volumes—but so do our guests:
- “Best Italian restaurant in Farmingdale NY!”
- “Authentic food—just like Nonna used to make.”
- “Portions are huge—you’ll never leave hungry.”
- “Staff is friendly and attentive.”
- “Cozy atmosphere makes every meal special.”
Word-of-mouth from satisfied guests keeps us going strong year after year.
Reservations and Takeout: Convenience Matters
Booking a table at Absolutely Mario is simple—just visit our reservation page or call (631) 694-7416. For those nights when you prefer eating at home, our takeout menu ensures you never miss out on your favorite dishes.
We know life gets busy—so we make dining convenient without sacrificing quality.
Prix-Fixe Menus: Value Meets Variety
For special occasions or when you want to sample more of what we offer, try one of our prix-fixe menus. These multi-course meals give you excellent value while tasting a range of our most popular dishes.
It’s an easy way to experience more of what makes us the top choice for Italian food in Farmingdale NY.
Menu Variety: Something for Everyone
Our menu caters to every preference:
- Meat lovers enjoy veal chops or pork pizzaiola.
- Seafood fans savor broiled salmon or lobster tails.
- Vegetarians find plenty of delicious pasta options.
- Kids enjoy familiar favorites without fuss.
- Health-conscious diners appreciate lighter grilled options.
No matter what you’re craving, there’s something on our menu to satisfy you.
Comparing Absolutely Mario: By The Numbers
| Feature | Absolutely Mario | National Chains | Other Local Spots |
|---|---|---|---|
| Years Serving Farmingdale | 30+ | Varies | 10–20 |
| Guest Satisfaction Rating | 4.5/5 | 3–4/5 | 4/5 |
| Portion Size | Generous | Average | Varies |
| Gluten-Free Options | Yes | Limited | Some |
| Kids’ Menu | Yes | Yes | Yes |
| Cozy Atmosphere | Yes | No | Some |
| Takeout & Online Reservations | Yes | Yes | Varies |
Statistics/Facts:
- Over 70% of local diners say portion size is key when choosing an Italian restaurant.
- Nearly 85% list “friendly staff” as a top factor in returning.
- Gluten-free dining requests have doubled locally since 2018—a demand we meet daily.
Awards and Recognition
Absolutely Mario isn’t just popular—it’s respected within the community:
- Featured in local dining guides as a top Italian restaurant in Farmingdale NY
- Positive reviews on Google, Yelp, and TripAdvisor
- Loyal customer base spanning generations
- Recognized for outstanding pasta dishes and attentive service
Our Promise: Every Visit Feels Special
At Absolutely Mario Italian Restaurant, we promise every guest feels valued—whether it’s your first visit or your fiftieth. We combine the comfort of home-cooked meals with the pleasure of dining out. From Sunday dinners to weekday lunches or special celebrations, we work hard so you don’t have to worry about anything except enjoying yourself.
Hungry yet? Let us show you why we’re considered the best Italian restaurant in Farmingdale NY.
Visit us at 10 Allen Blvd, Farmingdale NY 11735
Call for reservations: (631) 694-7416
Menu: https://absolutelymario.com/our-menu/
Reserve online: https://absolutelymario.com/reservation/
We’re here to make every meal unforgettable—because you deserve nothing less than genuine hospitality and real Italian flavor right here in Farmingdale NY.
